Image Optimizer for XF 2.0 [Paid] 2.2.1

[Wanderer]

Do not attempt to run this addon on 2.3.0 until the author releases a version that is explicitly labelled as 2.3.0-compatible.
It can result in a significant number of optimized PNG images getting outright deleted from the filesystem, with the only fix being restoring the files from backup and disabling the addon.

 

[TD Perry]

Do not attempt to run this addon on 2.3.0 until the author releases a version that is explicitly labelled as 2.3.0-compatible.
I did, and I believe it resulted in a bug where a significant number of optimized PNG images got deleted from the filesystem. The only fix was disabling the addon and restoring files from backup.

WandererIt's one of the reasons I have not upgraded. The niche of my site webP is not that nice with the images.
It is also why I have not upgraded this add-on past the 2.1.7 version as there are known bugs with images going "poof" when latter versions are installed.
Not to mention the fact, until the developer clearly tells you that the add-on is 2.3 compatible, you should NEVER assume so. That is not an issue with the developer but with the website administrator.

I comment on the upgrade issue here.

 

[Truonglv]

Just start reading from here forward

Image Optimizer for XF 2.0 [Paid]

Do you still get deleted images in latest version? @MattW @Artonn In the new version, if I want to look at [tl] Image Optimizer: Analyzes at /admin.php?tools/io-analyzes, I get a 404 error. 2024/02/20 14:02:11 [error] 20132#20132: *4683218 open() "/public_html/error/50x.html" failed (2: No...

xenforo.com

Seems a lot of people have been having issues and for use with 2.2 have settled on 2.1.7 since it was the last stable one.
Since the main part of my niche is images, I don't want to take a chance on losing them so let others find the issues.

TD PerryThis sites running in version 2.2.0 without any errors. If you can give steps to reproduce it, it would help to debug and fixing.

 

[TD Perry]

This sites running in version 2.2.0 without any errors. If you can give steps to reproduce it, it would help to debug and fixing.

TruonglvAs I said, I don't want to take the chance of losing a lot of images, so I've stayed on 2.1.7. You may want to engage with some of the people having issues on the XF forum. MattW is one that runs a hosting service and apparently he and some of his clients have had issues.

 

[Truonglv]

As I said, I don't want to take the chance of losing a lot of images, so I've stayed on 2.1.7. You may want to engage with some of the people having issues on the XF forum. MattW is one that runs a hosting service and apparently he and some of his clients have had issues.

TD PerryOK. I will contact with him to investigate the issues

 

[eva2000]

Popped in to just ask about XF 2.3 compatibility and guess I have the answer for now

xf list says 2.1.8 is latest though https://xenforo.com/community/resources/image-optimizer-for-xf-2-0.6030/updates but here shows 2.2.0 ?

 

[Truonglv]

Popped in to just ask about XF 2.3 compatibility and guess I have the answer for now

eva2000It almost completed yet. I will release in next few days.

 

[eva2000]

It almost completed yet. I will release in next few days.

Truonglvcheers looking forward to it

xf list says 2.1.8 is latest though https://xenforo.com/community/resources/image-optimizer-for-xf-2-0.6030/updates but here shows 2.2.0 ?

 

[Truonglv]

Truonglv updated Image Optimizer for XF 2.0 with a new update entry:

3.0.0

Notable changes:

• Support XenForo 2.3.0

Read the rest of this update entry...

 

[Wanderer]

Even after:
1) installing addon version 3.0.0 and updating it
2) downloading the latest webp from https://developers.google.com/speed/webp/download and installing it
3) re-running the setup file
3) going through the addon's file path references for pngquant, jpegoptim, gifsicle and cwebp to verify they work and are updated

This add-on STILL deletes my image files, and in a way that prevents me from removing the broken images via the admin attachments interface, unless I manually re-create their missing *.data files.

Here's an example of the file deletion bug from the debug log:

2024-08-02 03:51:02 Process images $contentType=attachment_data $lastRunId=122774 $images=5
2024-08-02 03:51:02 Begin optimize $id=122775
2024-08-02 03:51:04 Truonglv\ImageOptimizer\ContentData\AttachmentData:nSuccess
2024-08-02 03:51:04 file_hash changed ed405e481ec1474d7418ca1ca2a99772 -> b05ecac977420436fc35c11c40f1704f
2024-08-02 03:51:04 Copying /var/www/html/forum/internal_data/temp/tio_TxFiTm1722570662886 to internal-data://attachments/122/122775-074a64ceeca98ce0868bf88454799256.data
2024-08-02 03:51:04 Truonglv\ImageOptimizer\ContentData\AbstractData::removeAbstractFile(internal-data://attachments/122/122775-074a64ceeca98ce0868bf88454799256.data)
2024-08-02 03:51:04 Truonglv\ImageOptimizer\ContentData\AbstractData::removeAbstractFile(data://attachments/122/122775-074a64ceeca98ce0868bf88454799256.jpg)
2024-08-02 03:51:04 Truonglv\ImageOptimizer\ContentData\AttachmentData:nSuccess -> OK

Note that it SAYS it copied to internal-data://attachments/122/.... but it doesn't actually copy the file. It will happily update the database with the new file hash of the file, it will happily delete the old version of the file... but it won't save the new version of the file.

 

[eva2000]

Even after:
1) installing addon version 3.0.0 and updating it
2) downloading the latest webp from https://developers.google.com/speed/webp/download and installing it
3) re-running the setup file
3) going through the addon's file path references for pngquant, jpegoptim, gifsicle and cwebp to verify they work and are updated

This add-on STILL deletes my image files, and in a way that prevents me from removing the broken images via the admin attachments interface, unless I manually re-create their missing *.data files.

Here's an example of the file deletion bug from the debug log:

Note that it SAYS it copied to internal-data://attachments/122/.... but it doesn't actually copy the file. It will happily update the database with the new file hash of the file, it will happily delete the old version of the file... but it won't save the new version of the file.

Wanderermaybe the deletion step can have a check to verify the file has been copied first?

 

[Truonglv]

maybe the deletion step can have a check to verify the file has been copied first?

eva2000I added it now.

 

[aana]

Sadly, there is no way to recover it

TruonglvTruonglv
Can't your addon reprocess all the images ?

 

[Truonglv]

Truonglv
Can't your addon reprocess all the images ?

aanaYes if you reset offset it will run over again.